Toronto’s Flyers Sit Up to 87 Per Cent Under Average. Independent Grocers Need a Different Fight
Four staples in this week's Toronto flyers sit 23 to 87 per cent below national averages. IHR explains who funds those prices, what the Competition Bureau is reviewing, and where independent grocers should hold their ground.
By Yehuda B Abraham,
Chains can afford prices small stores cannot. What a Competition Bureau review changes, and where an independent should spend its effort instead.
Four staples in this week’s Toronto grocery flyers sit between 23 and 87 per cent below the national averages Statistics Canada recorded in August. Independent grocers cannot win that comparison on price, and the shoppers holding the flyers will make it anyway. The smarter question is which three prices to answer and which to let go.
Three owners, eleven banners, one price war
Open TorontoToday’s roundup of deals running Nov. 14 to 18 and the same names keep surfacing. At least nine of its 11 banners belong to Loblaw (Loblaws, No Frills, Real Canadian Superstore, T&T), Empire (Sobey’s, Farm Boy, FreshCo) or Metro (Metro, Food Basics). They fight over a handful of lines. Butternut squash runs $0.95 a pound at Farm Boy, $0.99 at No Frills and $1.49 at Food Basics. Chicken breast is $4.88 at Loblaws and Superstore, and a dime more at Food Basics.
| Flyer item | Flyer price | Normalized | Statistics Canada, Aug. 2026 | Flyer below average |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Potatoes, 10 lb bag (Sobey’s) | $2.99 | $0.66/kg | $5.17/kg | 87% |
| Eggs, 18 large white (Sobey’s) | $4.44 | $2.96/dozen | $4.83/dozen | 39% |
| Boneless skinless chicken breast (Loblaws, Superstore) | $4.88/lb | $10.76/kg | $14.41/kg | 25% |
| Lean ground beef (Metro) | $5.88/lb | $12.96/kg | $16.75/kg | 23% |
These are national averages, not shelf checks, so read the gaps as direction. The direction is steep enough. Grocery prices are up 33.0 per cent since September 2020, and although the annual rate slowed to 1.7 per cent in September, shoppers still trade flyer prices like scores. An independent that prices eggs at the average looks like the expensive option.
Who funds a flyer price, and why independent grocers cannot
The Competition Bureau found in 2023 that many independents lack the scale to run warehouses or buy direct, so some buy wholesale from operations tied to Loblaw and Empire. They pay on terms their competitors set.
The chains’ side of the ledger looks different. In the Bureau’s illustration of Loblaw’s former Active Ad Match Policy, a $2 product matched at $1.50 across 20,000 units produced a $10,000 supplier deduction. The shopper saw the low price. The supplier settled the difference. A small store has no fund like that to draw on.
A rulebook in flux
On Sept. 28, the Competition Bureau opened an investigation into minimum advertised pricing in grocery. It is asking whether those policies make deals harder to find, reduce price competition, create barriers for discount and new grocers, or make it easier for retailers to coordinate prices.
The camps do not line up the way you might expect. The Canadian Federation of Independent Grocers argues that lifting advertised-price restrictions would let the biggest chains promote prices smaller stores cannot meet. Its public policy lead, Gary Sands, warned of a “race to the bottom,” with small and remote communities hit hardest. For a discount grocer, advertising a lower price is central to the model. Retail Insider notes that Canadian evidence tying the policies to independents’ survival is thin.
The paradox is plain: the rule that mutes a flyer price may be the one shielding small stores from it.
A second rulebook is already live. The Canada Grocery Code has been in force since Jan. 1, with 200 businesses signed. It had drawn 14 complaints by May, and its first report found independents, like suppliers, reluctant to raise concerns with the companies they depend on. A complaint route nobody uses protects nobody.
Match the price and the profit goes first
Loblaw puts grocery profit margins at 3 to 4 per cent. The Retail Council of Canada, citing the Bureau, says 2 to 5. IHR found no published net margin for independents, so the chain range is the only benchmark.
At 3.5 per cent, a store keeps 3.5 cents of every dollar. Selling a dozen eggs $1.87 under the average gives up the net profit on roughly $53 of other sales. It is the same arithmetic IHR applied to what a Black Friday discount does to a supplement business.
The roundup also shows where the chains do not bother. It lists no supplement, no functional food and one plant-based product, a Silk beverage at $3.49 at Metro. It is one outlet’s selection, but chains advertise what a shopper can compare in two seconds. A buyer choosing a prenatal, a protein or a probiotic wants a name they trust, and a flyer cannot supply one. That is IHR’s read, not a measured finding, and it is where stores that sell on knowledge can hold margin.
Four moves before the next flyer lands
- Pick three signal prices. Choose items shoppers recall, such as eggs, chicken and one produce staple, and check them against the flyers weekly. Leave every other line at its normal margin.
- Get the wholesaler’s answer in writing. Ask what funding reaches featured lines and whether each supplier has signed the Grocery Code. Date every pricing conversation.
- Hand shelf-talker space to advice-led lines. Spend it where a staff recommendation changes the sale.
- Send your supplier terms to CFIG. The Bureau is gathering evidence, and independents’ own invoices are what it lacks.
This week’s flyers will be gone by Wednesday. The rules behind them will not, and the stores holding records of what they paid and what they were offered will be best placed when the Bureau reports.
Frequently Asked Questions
How long do these Toronto flyer prices last?
TorontoToday lists the deals as valid from Nov. 14 to 18 at downtown Toronto locations, unless a chain says otherwise. Prices can differ by store, so check the local flyer. A simple weekly log of the same four or five items shows how far shelf prices drift.
What is minimum advertised pricing?
It is a supplier rule setting the lowest price a retailer may advertise, not the lowest it may charge. The Competition Bureau’s example is a pasta package with a $2.99 advertised floor that a store could still sell at $1.99 if it did not advertise the price.
What is the Canada Grocery Code?
It is a voluntary framework governing dealings between grocers and suppliers, run by the Office of the Grocery Sector Code of Conduct. Empire, Loblaw, Metro, Walmart Canada and Costco Canada have registered. A dispute process exists as a last resort, and the code does not set shelf prices.
How many independent grocers are there in Canada?
The Competition Bureau cites Canadian Federation of Independent Grocers data of about 6,900 independent grocery stores. They range from single-store family operations to independent chains with dozens of locations. The Bureau has said that without government support, independents are unlikely to expand significantly in the near term.
This is independent editorial analysis of publicly advertised prices from a TorontoToday roundup. It names retailers as examples and is not an endorsement of any of them.
Sections: Business News Retail News
More in Business News
- When Your Bestseller Is Down to One Bottle, the Shelf Plan Is the Problem
- USADA Widens Its Supplement Certification List to Five Programs, and Shifts Proof to the Batch
- Pea Protein Now Has a Passport: What NordPea Means for Canadian Shelves
- The Pharmacist’s Touch: Why AI Makes the Counter Worth More
- Target’s New Director Built Clif Bar. Her Seat Signals What Canadian Wellness Brands Will Face at Target
- The US$2.50 Prenatal: A 15-Nutrient Yardstick for the Canadian Shelf